The Role of Sound in Video Games: Pong, Limbo and Interactivity
Recently, I’ve been amazed by how well the sound design of the new Xbox LIVE game Limbo has been able to coax me into various degrees of panic. Visually, the game is monochrome – black, white and various shades of grey sink into and out of the television as I guide the main character, a little boy, through the landscape of his nightmares. Tension builds as sound is used to announce off-screen dangers as they slowly creep across the screen. The muffled thud-thud of a giant spider on the left prompted me to run to the right where I suddenly encountered the deadly scream of a buzz-saw roaring toward me. It’s scary stuff. An ambient sound-layer is interrupted only by an occasional feedback crescendo or the rustling of the world’s many dangerous occupants. The soundtrack of Limbo says a lot about the game, which in turn says a lot about our culture. Video games are rarely the object of analysis for sound culture studies, this is fairly counterintuitive considering both their social impact and technological nature. Should sound studies take a closer look at video games – where would it start?
One option is to consider the game historically, as the convergence of several media discourses. First, there is cinema: The soundscape of Limbo borrows the formula that set the stage of desolation for so many low-budget horror movies. Consider the eerie silence of a horror movie like The Evil Dead and how there is a deliberate quiet within it’s conversation and music. These sonic memes are intended to invoke tension and surprise within the audience. Bruce Campbell, who plays the hapless protagonist, Ash, creeps through a similarly nightmarish landscape, inviting the listener into the soundscape of leaves, creaks, and screams. In a tradition, indebted to the aesthetics of Hitchcock, quiet soundscapes allow for broad dynamic shifts, juxtaposing safety and danger.
Another important discourse is that of video game history. Broad dynamic shifts in video games, have not always been the result of a deliberate horror aesthetic. Video games lacked sound until the release of Computer Space in 1971. A year later, the same creative team, Nolan Bushnell and Ted Dabney, would later found Atari and release Pong. Though Pong was a clone of an electric ping-pong game for 1966’s Magnavox Odyssey, Bushnell convinced Al Alcorn, the lead engineer, to hack-in sound. Silence, blips and beeps were for almost 25 years a result of hard technological limits in video games. As CD driven consoles were released in the mid-nineties, game sound was able to become more sophisticated, eventually integrating popular music seamlessly into games like Tony Hawk Pro Skater. Although game soundtracks were no longer constrained by the draconic limitations of console circuits (The Atari VCS was often unable to set its two lead voices to a similar scale – Karen Collins describes this more fully in her article “In the Loop”), game sounds still depend on the limitations of programming code. Limbo offers the latest technology, sound designer Martin Stig Anderson, has explained how advances in programming language have helped him to accommodate dramatic shifts in player control.
Game sound has always focused on the interactive, and Limbo is a great example of this development. Although games like Super Metroid and Portal have used ambient sound to emulate cinema, Limbo presents a living soundscape. Able to freely traverse the world, players can control the score of Limbo, a sign that music is becoming interactive in new ways. Is this a meaningful sign of technological convergence, or simply a reiteration of the existing aesthetic tropes? You decide.
6 responses to “The Role of Sound in Video Games: Pong, Limbo and Interactivity”
Trackbacks / Pingbacks
- February 27, 2023 -
- October 7, 2013 -
- March 25, 2013 -
- December 7, 2012 -
- December 26, 2011 -
Just came across this. Great post. I have recently completed Limbo (my favourite game of 2010, other than Red Dead Redemption) and was struck by how effective the sound design was, and too the sparse use of etheral ambient music (oddly some reviews had suggested Limbo had no music at all). The effectivness of the sound design in this game to enhance the mood / feeling, rather than just using standard “stock sounds” to make the game world sound correct almost reminds me of Akira Yamaoka’s work on the Sillent Hill games, add to this the use of silence in both games as a tension building device.
I played this game quite loudly on a nice surround system and some moments of that game were truely amazing and artistic, truely enhanced by the sound – The low vibrating bass hum drone as the spider crawls onto screen from the shadows made me shiver a little, The harshness (and loudness) of the buzz saws which I agree were quite scary, the peaceful layers of etheral music that come to a sudden stop as you walk over a leaver to open a gate (tyre puzzle), or the last suprise moment as the game slows down and you freefall peacefully through the air and back to the start where all the natural foley sound fades back in, now clearly contrasted with all the mechanical sounds that had preceded it. Felt like a journey playing it. I have to admit the visual aesthetic also plays a huge part in how great this game was for me.
I found that Audiokinectic interview with Martin Anderson very interesting as I too wanted get to the nitty gritty of how the sound design was developed for Limbo. As you might tell, I get quite excited about the potential for sound design in games, particuarly the more original, and horror style games.